I hate to be the voice of reason
but that would just hurt feelings, piss people off and eventually create more work for our beloved moderators because they wouldn't be moderating a website anymore, they would be moderating fights.
Are y'all really looking to invite the drama? LOL That's the one thing I love the most about AC is the lack of drama!
As much as I would love to see banners disappear all together, I think deleting the ones that don't follow the rules is punishment enough, and the idea about deleting stories after a second offense would certainly get the point across. Publicly pointing them out would just be mean haha. Unless that's what you're going for? lol I know how Mare likes to pretend she's evil sometimes. Oddly enough I can totally see her and julilly both sitting in a corner together cackling together as they deviously hit the delete button over and over.