In fan fiction it's often challenging to create an original character that stands out more than the characters people know and love. Often times (especially in the case of the BSB fandom) those characters are the female lead.
The following nominees created original female characters that are loved as much (if not more) than their male counterparts.
The nominees for Best Female are:
Shelby in Love Story by evergreenwrite
r83
Shelby in Babies and the Band by evergreenwrite
r83
Olivia in With The Band by evergreenwrite
r83
Morgan in Once In A Blue Moon by summer
And the winner is...
Winner:
Morgan in Once In A Blue Moon by summerRunner Up: Olivia in With The Band by evergreenwrite r83