Thanks Guys for the Mizpah mentions.
I think I actually do have three of these!
1. Ground Zero by Chaos - I know everyone has said this one but there's a reason for it! I think it's probably the best BSB suspense I have ever read. If it weren't for this story, I doubt I would have ever really had the bug to write anything at all so I owe Chaos a big cookie for this one! I still wish and hope that one day when we least expect in a very Chaos way, the sequel will be updated and finished.
2. Children Like Me by Mersey - This is a Supernatural/BSB crossover and it was a great angsty suspense when Nick discovers he's got some special things happening in his life, he encounters the Winchester Brothers who help the guys out. Vague I know but read it! lol You don't even really have to be a fan of Supernatural to enjoy it.
3. I have two i'm going to say here - Fear Factor by Mersey - It's a Nick and Kevin suspense. I loved it, the only problem is it's not compete!
3.5 - Seven Days by Refuse - I was hesitant to put this because I consider this more action/adventure than suspense, but it does have some really intense suspense moments. I love this story it's one of my all time favorites!
honorable mention: Satan's Playground by Reb (the original one) this was a great start. I'm sad she gave up on it. It was an uber creepy and intense read!