I'm choosing the one after Nick's Logic (M&Ms) and the brotherly interaction has a lot to do with why I'm picking it too
I love all the subtle comparisons between Nick&Brian and Sam&Dean. Nick himself summarises it perfectly at the end saying "What was it about short, big brothers that really get on the nerves of taller, little brothers?" LOL And I was awwwing at Brian saying that he would follow Nick if he decided to start hunting (and how that would be a problem with his wife but would make his son consider him a way cooler dad lol).
Then there's the whole M&M thing (have to love those
) and this is the chapter where they are starting to act like a team of 'hunters' (well hunters in training lol) with Howie organizing things and AJ volunteering to learn Latin (ROTFL) and then AJ being all AJ about the car hehe
Oh and you know how much I LOVE chapter 15 too mersey (since I practically forced you to post it hehe) which is a perfect and hilarious portrait of the Winchesters but like the title says it, that one was kind of an 'intermission' in the story, that's why I'm choosing chapter 11 as my favorite chapter.