Fic Talk > General Discussion
Question of the day part 9 (even though days go by lol)
RokofAges75:
Along the lines of what I said in my last post...
On AC, go into your Account Info and Reviews Received and look at your stats. What is your highest-reviewed story? How about your lowest-reviewed? Why do you think these two stories got the amount of reviews they did?
Rose:
My highest reviewed (solo/not collab) story is Remember Me This Way. While it's a total Nick angst fest it's really about the bromance too. I'd like to think it's so well reviewed because people loved the story. I've said this repeatedly but I feel like my best writing (or some of) went into that.
My highest reviewed fic over all is Song For The Undead and I think Julie and I have just done a great job. Like trend wise it's against all of them. It's AU, it's horror, it's long, and there's 5 original main characters along with the Boys. So I think that stands up on the writing we've done together since it was started BEFORE my fave show Walking Dead got everyone on the zombie train lol.
My lowest reviewed story is a fic called "Lost Souls" (that has a legit amount of chapters and isn't a oneshot). And that's pretty much because I was a very new writer in fanfic, only like 14/15 years old. So I was an unknown, I didn't know as much as I do now... lots of reasons really. It's a mess lol.
RokofAges75:
My highest-reviewed is Curtain Call with 1,172 reviews. It was helped by the fact that it's pretty long (90 chapters), although not Broken/BMS long. But a lot of people just really liked that story! It had a loyal following that left me reviews til the bitter end, and I guess that's how it racked up so many. I'm very grateful!
My lowest-reviewed is a tie between two of my one-shots, Adelaide and Seduction of Evil, which both have 2 reviews. Neither surprises me, since they're both old stories. Adelaide is original fiction, so I didn't see the fanfic crowd getting into that one, and Seduction of Evil is kind of like a bad R.L. Stine story, so again... not surprised. I think I only posted that one because I was one story away from having a nice round number next to my name on AC LOL.
My lowest-reviewed novel is Identical, with 5 reviews. I think the main reason that number is so low is that I posted the whole story at once back in 2005, several years after I wrote it, so it wasn't like I was ever updating it on AC. It's not my best work, either, but it's not a bad story. It got pretty good feedback on my site back in the day.
FrickingKaos:
my highest reviewed story is Figured You Out with a total of 309 reviews.
my lowest is my one shot challenge story Howie Snaps, it only has four...probabl y cause it is a Howie story and it is only two chapters long *shrugs*
It doesn't surprise me that FYO had so many reviews, it was well liked and a lot of people read it so I am quite pleased. I am just happy to even get one review, I never expected so many to like that story because I was scared to death to post it when I started to write it.
Rose:
My lowest reviewed oneshot is a tie between one called "A New Era" which was about Nick's POV post Unbreakable. Which, I don't think it's bad. It's just thoughtful. Not sure why it went unnoticed lol.
The other is an AJ one called "Tough Lover" which is basically a psycho fan having AJ hostage told from her POV. I liked it but who knows why it got two reviews. I was shocked when it got nominated for something just because of that haha.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version