Fic Talk > General Discussion
Questions to ponder part 11
mare:
--- Quote from: RokofAges75 on June 27, 2014, 09:28:35 PM ---A follow-up question that came to mind as I was thinking of classics was, what qualifies as a "classic" in your mind? Does it have to be a story of a certain age? If so, where do you draw the line? If not, what constitutes a newer classic?
I tend to draw the line around 2003, but hell, that's 11 years ago! I think that's just my own personal cut off because it coincides with a major change in my life, graduating high school and starting college, as well as me coming into my own as a fanfic writer. I tend to divide my own work into two eras, pre-Broken and post-Broken, since Broken is the first truly popular story I wrote and was a lot better than anything I'd written before it. Some of you probably weren't even involved with fanfic then, though, so I'm curious to see what you consider classic.
--- End quote ---
I was going to make this a fourth questions but decided not to. LOL great minds...
RokofAges75:
--- Quote from: mare on June 27, 2014, 09:30:52 PM ---I was going to make this a fourth questions but decided not to. LOL great minds...
--- End quote ---
LOL Indeed!
I also realized after I posted my answer that 2003 was also in the midst of the big hiatus, which separated "Chapter 1" of BSB's career from the Never Gone era and beyond. When I think classic BSB, I think of their pre-Never Gone albums, so I guess I think of fanfics the same way.
mare:
Is there a 'classic' story you have always wanted to read but never have gotten around to?
I'm pretty sure all the classics I wanted to read I have. I guess the only one that's still alluded me is that one with Brian and AJ. I can't remember the name of it and I didn't read it because it's Brian and AJ but everyone really seemed to love it. LOL
Is there a 'classic' story you have read because everyone recommended it but when you read it, you didn't like it?
Yeah, Julie was right. I picked Faceless to read for FFF because of the glowing reviews and regretted every single chapter of it, except the first one. I liked the newspaper article. (sorry person who wrote it. I feel bad but I'm sure there's someone out there saying the same thing about my stuff too. lol) I also wasn't a fan of Signal To Noise either though. Too disturbing for me.
Name five stories you consider 'classics' and why you think people should check them out.
1) Ground Zero - probably the best oldie suspense fic out there. Seriously, without reading this one, I'm not sure I would have ever even considered writing.
2) Seven Days - My all time favorite action story. Loved the plot and pace and the villain was awesome as well.
3) Documentaries - My all time favorite short story. Just a really great emo plot. I still think Izzy writes the only AJ I really enjoy reading lol
4) Come Together - The best how the band got together story.
5) Can You Keep A Secret - My favorite medical/bromantic story. So many cute moments between the guys. Just lovely.
I probably would have included Where Can We Go From Here on my list as well. Loved that one!
mare:
I think for me a classic isn't really about a specific time period, but more how the story seems revered. If people do nothing but go on and on about a story, it ends up being a classic, whether it was written in 1999 or 2014. Or you mention the name of an author and the first words out of someone's mouth is, "Oh they wrote...so and so..."
I would personally consider Broken a classic. I think when people hear your name, it's one of the first stories that will pop into people's heads. The girl who wrote Broken.
That would be another great question. When you say a certain author's name, what's the first story that pops into your head?
balance:
Is there a 'classic' story you have always wanted to read but never have gotten around to?
"Between the Lines" by Carrie.
Is there a 'classic' story you have read because everyone recommended it but when you read it, you didn't like it?
"Enigma" by Paulla. It was on a lot of rec lists at the time. Very intriguing story about Nick who is plagued by a recurring nightmare. He and the other guys go on an adventure to try and help him and what they discover is "out of this world." The plot was unlike anything I had read at the time; however, it was a hard read for me because the flow of the story seemed to be off....it felt and read really choppy.
Name five stories you consider 'classics' and why you think people should check them out.
Wow....tough one!
1. ) "Ground Zero" by Chaos - While on tour, Nick goes missing and is found and reunited with the other Boys. However, Nick's kidnapper wants him back!- The suspense in this story makes it timeless! It grabs the reader's attention and does not let go of it. And though it is completed now, when I first read it, it was the one story I had to check to see if it was updated!
2.) "Several Days in the Life of the Backstreet Boys or Two Weddings and a "Fine Mess You've Gotten Us Into!" by Marly. - Marly's stories are funny, but there is also a little drama. But what I think makes this a classic is the writer's internal dialogue for Nick. His thoughts provoke laugh out loud, belly laughs for me. It was also one of the first stories I read where there was no Frick-and-Frack dynamic.
3.) "The Legend" by Whitney. - Two tattered worlds. A legend long forgotten. A galaxy on the verge of annihilation. A group of unlikely heroes who never asked for the task that fate has bestowed upon them…
These ten alone are the only ones who can save their worlds, but to do so they must embark on a journey of peril and hardship that will take them across the stars and test their faith in themselves and everything they have ever believed in. All they know is that they must survive to fight the ultimate battle of good against evil, for if they do not triumph all will be lost. - This story was a bunch of firsts for me....first sci-fi, first AU, and first crossover (Nsync is included) and would be the story I would recommend for anyone who has not tried these genres. The writing is stellar and it's just a good read!
4.) "The Answer is Yes" by Eboni. - Nick Carter and Justin Timberlake are kidnapped by aliens. Now they must work together to get back home. Another sci-fi story added to my list! This story is not a group story but a Nick and Justin story and would probably not be the most would name when talking about Eboni. However, what makes this story a classic is the writing. Eboni's descriptions of these aliens and alien worlds are vivid and are easy to see in the mind's eye. Her original characters are likable and she almost made me like Justin Timberlake.... almost.
5.) "Snapshots" by Jennifer Stevens. - One Backstreet Boy goes missing in Washington, D.C. "Snapshots" is a character study of the Backstreet Boys. There are five chapters to the story and each chapter heading used a word to describe the subject of that particular chapter: Gorgeous - Kevin, Loving - Howie, O? - Brian (can't remember), Rebel - AJ, and Youth - Nick. Each chapter gives the reader the characters' innermost thoughts and you get a glimpse of the friendship that makes the Backstreet Boys. And while you're reading this, you still have the drama of the missing Boy.
This was hard just narrowing down to 5, but these were the first to pop into my head.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version