My top three favorite old-school plots were the kidnapping stories, the crash stories (bus, car, plane - loved them all!), and the Brian heart problem stories. I read so many of those!
I agree, Mare, it's definitely harder to come up with situations in which you can get the Boys all together without any of the family members around. I love that they rented that house in London to write for IAWLT because it shows that the scenario of having them go somewhere all together to get away or get some work done is still realistic.
But remember the teenybopper stories that had them all living in the same house? Usually right next door to the house that Mary Sue and her four BFFs lived in? And across the street from NSYNC's house? LOL