Fic Talk > General Discussion
Review Site
nicksgal:
I have some left over from my term papers and a couple from creative writing, so...
And Rose, yup, just ask. :) I don't remember if I read the last chapter you wrote, but... everything that was up on Ethereality, I read. :)
RokofAges75:
The creative writing ones might be helpful, Dee.
Purpura, do you have anything that you used on your review site?
We really just need to make a list of areas we're critiquing, maybe sub-areas too, and a point value for each one... then we could just add up the points for a grand total at the end. Each subarea would be worth a different amount of points based on how important we think it is.
RokofAges75:
Adding onto what I just posted, it would be helpful to also have a brief description of what each point value would look like.
Example: For grammar/spelling/mechanics (whatever we want to label that as), if it was worth 5 points, to get a 5, the story would have to be basically perfect (maybe a typo or two, but no blatant mistakes). For a 4, a few more mistakes but still well-written. 3 would be average, not horrible but not stellar either. 2, pretty bad, lots of mistakes. 1, hardly readable LOL.
nicksgal:
Yup, that looks just like my school rubrics. :D
Purpura Lipstick:
those are like many school rubrics and make "grading" things soooo much easier.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version