Fic Talk > General Discussion
Review Site
honey:
Sometimes I reply with my reaction to what happened. I talk to the characters and such just as if I were yelling at the movie screen. You know like, "OMG No no no! Nicky you can't do that!!!!! She's gonna be so pissed!" Some reviewers do that to my stories too. It's not necessarily the most constructive review, but it helps the reader see your enthusiasm for the story and that feels good too. (Or maybe just have a good laugh. Haha. I'm sure many have had a good laugh at my expense.)
or, in case you're not as silly as me and don't groan out loud at the TV every time Lana accuses Clark of keeping secrets, or yell when Clark walks into a room where he should just know there a bunch of Kryptonite. (I love my Superman and all, but he's not always the sharpest tool in the shed if you know what I mean.) another thing people do is say what they thing is going to happen next. I love it when people leave their theories of the story. It's very interesting to see where everyone thinks you're headed with the plot. I got some interesting theories when people were trying to figure out who Cindy's prince charming was going to be.
but I agree with Julie. "Great job!", "loved the chapter" and can't wait for an update" are still better than nothing. The least they know you're reading that way.
mare:
^ When I review I like to review as I read so this way I say things that are still fresh in my mind. I also enjoy when people quote something they liked in the story and explain why or same with quoting something they didn't understand. It helps me as a writer know what people like and dislike.
I do appreciate al the good jobs as well though. :)
RokofAges75:
I like getting the reactions too, Kelly - it makes me smile. When I review, depending on the story, sometimes I review as I go (usually if it's a long chapter, so I don't forget anything) and put in my reactions or parts I really liked, like Mare said. Othertimes I just review after I finish reading the whole thing and just give a summary of what I liked. And sometimes it really is hard to find something specific to say, even if I did like the chapter, but I figure anything is better than nothing.
Also, for anyone who gets shy about giving feedback, just know that no matter what you say or how you say it, as long as it's something positive, the author will appreciate hearing it. There are no stupid questions, and there are no stupid reviews (except for flames LOL). If the author doesn't appreciate it, then they're not worth your time, but most of us do. ;)
mare:
^ yes and to add to that, if you do feel the need to point out a flaw of some kind, make sure you say something nice first. Like wow I loveed the dialogue in the middle but there was one part towards the end that didn't seem very believeable to me...then point it out. If criticism is said nicely no one minds I don't think, but yeah...eh that sucked monkey butts is not a good way to get across how you feel lol
RokofAges75:
--- Quote from: mare on June 27, 2007, 11:56:15 AM ---^ yes and to add to that, if you do feel the need to point out a flaw of some kind, make sure you say something nice first. Like wow I loveed the dialogue in the middle but there was one part towards the end that didn't seem very believeable to me...then point it out. If criticism is said nicely no one minds I don't think, but yeah...eh that sucked monkey butts is not a good way to get across how you feel lol
--- End quote ---
Exactly! I said positive because I know that some people do get offended by criticism, even the constructive kind, but most writers that have been writing long enough have reached the point where they value constructive criticism if it's put nicely. But definitely... if you're going to say something negative, even if you don't think it's anything major, always include something positive too. Let the positive outweigh the negative. If you can't think of enough positive to balance the negative, then maybe that story isn't for you.
Oh, and also be detailed about the negative - if you say you don't like the chapter, you better say what you didn't like about it, or the author's going to wonder way more than they'll wonder what you liked if you just say "great chapter!" and don't elaborate. It's unfortunate, but you always remember the negative more than the positive LOL.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version