I love looking for stories that have really unqiue plots. Not weird, lol. Unique. Such as Paralyzed Heart or 5 Backstreet Boys In Search Of A Plot. I really like drama and angst, because I go through that a lot. And not high school drama that seems to follow you as you get older. Real life drama. I love stories that can stir up all my emotions and almost bring me in with the characters.
I abhor fictions were a BSB is best friends with a girl and either the girl falls in love with the boy or the boy falls in love with the girl... etc. It's such a tired plot and I will not even touch one that is like that. Also plots that have no point or are reminiscent of our teenybopper days is completely out.