Oh, fun!
I'm guessing the shooting took place at about 10:59 PM, and Carter questioned the guest at about 11:54 PM. If that were the case, the hands would have just switched places. At 10:59, the hour hand would be almost to the 11, and the minute hand would be almost to the 12. At 11:54, the hour hand would be almost to the 12, and the minute hand would be almost to the 11. If you weren't looking carefully at the length of the hands, you might think they hadn't moved.