Since this idea has been getting so much discussion in the stars thread, I thought I'd start a new thread for it.
We've been talking about starting one of those review sites, where authors can submit their stories to be read and critiqued in a comprehensive, detailed review. I think the goal right now is to connect it to AC somehow, but that's up to Chaos, and I don't know his take on it.
In any case, the idea so far is to get maybe one or two reviewers for each genre; those reviewers would only read stories in that genre, to keep it as fair and non-biased as possible. We would have to come up with some sort of rubric with different areas and point values for a story to be rated on.
So if you think it's a good idea and are interested at all (in planning the rubric, actually reviewing, sending your story in, anything!), jump in and add your two cents!
