Reviews For Finding Carter
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:22 pm Title: Epilogue

This was a great epilogue. I love that Nick's all grown up, married, and doing what he loves. I love, love, LOVE the names of his kids, and I do get the Disney references! LOL I also love that Howie's a janitor at Nick's work. Hehe! The scene between Brian and Nick at the bar after work was cute. I'm glad they're still close - as they should be, being brothers and all! You did a great job bringing everything full circle in this ending and yet also showing the growth Nick made as the main character. He really changed over the course of the story, and that's the mark of good storytelling! Great job with this one, Tracy. It was different, but I enjoyed it!

Author's Response: I chose those names carefully. I think Peter was perfect because Nick really loves Peter Pan so much, and Andy for Toy Story due to his and Brian's nicknames. I am also glad that him growing up felt real for you and that he changed, because that is just what I wanted to do. I was so proud of this story when I wrote it and it's probably my second favorite that I've done, so thank you so much for all the critiquing and feedback, I really do appreciate everything you've said and will think about all of this for when I do write a new story. Once again, thanks so much for choosing mine for the challenge.

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:19 pm Title: Chapter 29

I was surprised to see the story jump three years to graduation, but it was nice to see that after all his worrying, Nick made it. And also that he and Laura are together; I wasn't expecting that either! I'm glad Brian made peace with his parents, and the exchange between Nick and Kevin at the end of this chapter was really sweet.

Author's Response: I did that because I wanted to wrap the story up and kind of fast forward, I know it was a bit sudden but I felt graduating was a major event and needed to show once again how he's progressed as a student and in life itself. College is supposed to be a growing period and I think Nick is finally figuring things out. I love writing Nick and Kevin together, definitely gives me warm fuzzies :)

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:18 pm Title: Chapter 28

I like that Brian's now living with Nick and Kevin (and discovering something he's not good at, bussing tables LOL) and Nick's getting his license. I'm also glad Nick talked to Brian's mom and is now making Brian talk to his mom too. Things really are wrapping up nicely now.

Author's Response: Yep they sure are. thanks for the reviews. I am sad they are ending because I would get excited and look forward to reading and responding to reviews again. Glad you are enjoying the story and gave it another chance. I know I've said it before but I really was excited that you were reading this when I found out.

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:17 pm Title: Chapter 27

This chapter could have worked as the ending; it seemed to wrap things up quite nicely! I loved the conversation where Nick asked Brian if he was ever worried he was going to fail at life. That was just such a real moment, something I'm sure all people worry about at that age.

Author's Response: I think you could be right about that. See, I wanted to show Nick after college as well so that is why the story ends in the way that it did, I needed to show Nick grew up in the course of the story and I think it worked very well. That's what the title is about...Finding Carter is about him finding himself so to speak. I also definitely think college kids do worry about failing at some point or another, I'm glad this sounded real for you because I never got to experience college myself and was hoping that the emotion was real.

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:14 pm Title: Chapter 26

I was a little confused on if Laura and Lana were twins or just friends, since it mentioned both in the chapter, but I guess it doesn't matter - Nick's gonna get laid! I hope this encounter goes better than his date with Crystal LOL.

Author's Response: I just read through the chapter again this morning and realized I made an error....you were the only one to catch that. Lana and Laura were twin sisters, I have to go and fix that so thanks for pointing it out to me.

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:12 pm Title: Chapter 25

I loved the quote from The Great Mouse Detective at the top of this one; that is one of my favorite underrated, not-as-well-known Disney movies! I also loved the scene in the car where they were listening to the radio, especially this line: "Some guy was asking if he was sexual. I raised my eyebrow. Who wrote this stuff?" LMAO Love it.

Author's Response: I have actually never seen the movie but I saw it on Netflix. Might be worth checking out someday...but I liked the quote for this chapter. What I did was write the chapter, then go to the Disney Words twitter to find a quote that fit it. I love taking digs at his real life personality, its pretty fun haha. thanks so much Julie!!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:10 pm Title: Chapter 24

Poor Brian LOL. The scene of him drunk-dialing his mom and cussing her out was painfully awkward, but entertaining to read! And poor Nick, too, for having to put up with him later and getting kicked in the balls and puked on! LOL Also, that's funny that Howie got kicked out of the frat and ended up changing colleges out of embarrassment.

Author's Response: I loved that scene of Brian being drunk and cussing his mom out. Nick got his payback for earlier in the story from puking on Brian, guess that makes them even LOL.

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:09 pm Title: Chapter 23

I'm glad Nick finally told Brian the truth in this chapter! It was hard reading them arguing; Brian was right to call Nick out on shutting him out. Still, I can't imagine how much that news must have blown Brian's mind!

Author's Response: It was great to finally have Nick tell him everything. The fight was hard for me to write because they've been getting along so well, but Brian needed to do that because holding things in is not good at all. I can't imagine finding out someone was related to me after knowing them for a few months, it would blow my mind too. Thanks for reading!!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:07 pm Title: Chapter 22

I'm glad Nick and Brian were both basically okay. Poor Nick, though, now he'll never want to drive!

Author's Response: See, this is what turned me off of driving in the first place. Was in a accident as a kid in my parents station wagon.....then again years later when my grandmother had a hit and run. She ran into the guy and kept driving, her hood was bent halfway up the windshield and the car was all bent up, she drove it from my school to my house. It was terrifying and ever since then I just have a thing about cars. Thanks for reviewing!!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:06 pm Title: Chapter 21

I knew it was going to be a car accident! I was like "Oh no you didn't!" when I read this LOL. Poor Nick, he'd really have a complex if Brian was killed in a car accident too!

Author's Response: Yeah, can you imagine if he did? thanks for the review!!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/26/13 02:40 am Title: Epilogue

Okay, first of all, I got on a roll and finished reading this on my Kindle last night! I loved the ending, but I will go back and comment in more detail on the last however many chapters when I catch up on my reviewing.

I just finished reading your responses to my reviews, and I actually just wanted to respond back to some of those! First of all, I love that you put in the cranberry sauce reference as an intentional joke! I kind of wondered about that because it was a running joke on AC for awhile, but I knew that was a long time ago before I remember you being on the forum a lot, so I thought maybe it was just coincidence LOL.

Second, about the fear or driving - I used to feel the same way, and I didn't even have a good reason, like having been in an accident before. I did not enjoy learning to drive, and it took me forever to get enough practice hours in to get my license. I didn't get it until I was 17. It was a few years before I really feel comfortable driving, especially with anyone else in the car, but now I don't mind it at all. It IS something you can get over if you push yourself to do it. That is a good goal to have! Just had to tell you that! :)

Author's Response: Yeah I sometimes go through threads on AC when I am bored, it's fun to read through some of them and I remember Julilly talking about cranberry sauce. I think I used it in my one shot Reindeer Games as well, Nick getting hit by the reindeer because he just wanted the canned cranberry sauce LOL. It seems to be a running gag in my stories now. I am working on getting my license, studying here and there, but I am gonna try. Hopefully one day I will get it like Nick did. Thanks so much for reading and enjoying the story, all your feedback really meant a lot to me and I am glad that the ending was to your satisfaction!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/25/13 07:33 am Title: Chapter 20

I can understand how awkward that must be for Nick to hide such a secret from Brian. It's a good thing they ended up getting along, but I wonder what Kevin would have done if it turned out they didn't like each other? Just never tell them the truth? I wonder if Nick will really tell Brian the truth during their trip, or if something else will prevent it from happening. I feel like you're doing some foreshadowing with Nick's premonition that something's going to go wrong. I'm worried it's going to be a car accident, for as much as Nick's been obsessing about that, though I can understand his fear. The line about Death finding him reminded me of Final Destination LOL.

Author's Response: Well, you'll just have to wait and see. I can identify with Nick in this story with his fear of driving....that has been a fear of mine since I was young. I was in a accident with my grandmother and it pretty much turned me off of driving....but I am really trying to overcome that and get my license. I love Final Destination and that line reminds me of it too. thanks for the reviews, you rock!!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/25/13 07:30 am Title: Chapter 19

Well it's about time someone told him! I love the way you wrote that scene, with Kevin drunkenly saying it in the midst of the countdown to the new year. That added the perfect touch of drama!

Author's Response: thank you so much, Julie. Kevin practically wrote that scene for me, I knew I wanted to have him drunk when he told Nick and New Year's was perfect. Glad you liked it because it was one of my favorite scenes.

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/25/13 01:54 am Title: Chapter 18

Ahh, tell him already, Harold!! I love that Kevin got Nick a Harry Potter book for Christmas, and the toilet seat thing was funny too. I like that Nick's finally accepted Buzz as a nickname. Buzz and Woody... cute. I can't wait for them to find out the truth!

Author's Response: Harold just kept fighting me when I wanted to have him be the one to tell Nick, so I went with another option instead. I think Buzz fits Nick well because Brian is Woody. the toilet seat was a Harry Potter reference because Fred and George promised Ginny a Hogwarts one, so I thought it would be funny to include it. thanks for the review!!

Reviewer: RokofAges75 Signed [Report This]
Date: 06/25/13 01:51 am Title: Chapter 17

Aww, I felt sorry for Nick when he woke up from his dream and Brian said he was calling for his mom. :( The part with the cow and Nick being afraid of the rooster was funny. I laughed at the whole thing about cranberry sauce. I don't know if you were on AC then, but there was a whole conversation about canned cranberry sauce there years ago - Julilly HATES the stuff. I much prefer the real thing myself; it's my favorite part of Thanksgiving! I can't imagine preferring the canned stuff compared to that! Poor Nick, he doesn't know what he's missing! LOL

Author's Response: I loved the part about the rooster, it really cracked me up writing it. I have a confession to make, when I was writing this story I was kind of going through the old threads on AC forum and came across a convo about cranberry sauce. For some reason I do not like the fresh one myself, my grandmother had put it on the table at thanksgiving and I wouldn't eat it. Luckily my dad had brought a can for me so I had the canned stuff, I like it so much better. So I always joke about it, this is probably the second story I have referenced cranberry sauce in. thanks for the review Julie!!