Okay, the tie is broken! 3 votes to "Kissed By an Angel" by Elizabeth Chandler, so that's what we're reading! It's already almost July, so get your books ASAP. I'll hold off at least a week till we start reading and discussing to give you some time.
Just a reminder, this book is technically a trilogy, but it's usually sold all in one collection, which is necessary because it's really one continuous story, and you don't get much of a resolution until the end of the third. So we're reading the whole thing this month (don't worry, it's not that long even put all together).
Here's a link to the version you'll want to buy:
http://www.amazon.com/Kissed-Angel-Power-Love-Soulmates/dp/1416978836/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1246211388&sr=8-1If anyone's getting it from a library or something, this is the old cover (this is the version I have), just so there's no confusion:
http://www.fantasticfiction.co.uk/c/elizabeth-chandler/kissed-by-angel.htm