LOL That's true. I would never expect them to gush over any story because reading about yourself like that has to be too weird to truly enjoy, but I could see them getting a kick out of some of the things we write about them, and that would be kind of cool.
I think for me, though, it would depend on the story. There are a couple I wouldn't mind knowing they'd read, even if they did think they were weird. Most of them I would be slightly embarrassed about, but no big deal. The one I really wouldn't want them, especially Nick, to read is Broken. Probably Curtain Call too, but Broken is the one that would bother me the most. Of course, that's the one I'm probably best known for LOL. Luckily, Nick seems to know that fanfic is scary and he should just stay away. Far, far away LOL.