My biggest story success would have to be with the Nick cancer stories - the Broken series and Curtain Call. It's hard for me to pick between them because they were both successful in different ways. Curtain Call is the most reviewed story on AC and the first of mine to make it on the ten favorite stories list, but Broken was the story that sort of put me and my website on the fanfic map back in 2003. Curtain Call is better written by far, but I don't think I could have written it as well if I hadn't written Broken first. Broken taught me so much about writing. Besides the response they got from readers, what I'm most proud of about both stories are the strong characters I created for them and all the research I did to make them realistic.
My biggest story failure... well, two weeks ago, I might have said Guilty Roads LOL, but since I'm feeling better about that one now, I'd have to go with any of my discontinued collaborations over the years. There have been some epic failures in that bunch, including a Deep Impact-esque apocalyptic tale about the Backstreet Boys surviving a comet that's on a collision course toward Earth! LOL Again, I'm having a tough time deciding which is the biggest failure, but the two I feel the worst about not finishing are Code Blue and a story called Now or Never that isn't even on AC. Those were the two that had the most potential. Now or Never suffered from not enough planning and, consequently, a fatal case of writer's block. Code Blue probably suffered from too MUCH planning and too much of everything - characters, storylines, and writers. Hopefully 00Carter can hang in there and avoid the same fate.
I think my biggest fanfic success in general would have to be my website. I started Dreamer's Sanctuary in April 2000 and have maintained it for the last 13 years. Before I did a complete overhaul and moved it to Wordpress last year, it was probably the biggest BSB fanfic site still being updated that wasn't an eFiction-style archive, like AC. Since I'm no longer hosting stories, I don't have that claim to fame anymore (although all 170+ stories are still on my domain), but DS is still one of the best-known BSB fanfic sites. It's one of the first to come up in searches and one of the first to be mentioned when people ask for places to go to read good stories. A lot of that has happened by default, since most of its competition is no longer online or no longer being updated, but still, I'll take it!
My biggest fanfic failure would be just not reading as much of it as I used to. I used to obsessively scour the internet for stories to read and spend hours each day reading them. I wouldn't say I read anything and everything - there were still storylines that grabbed my attention more than others - but I read a LOT! Nowadays, I don't read nearly as much. There are still stories that I follow and look forward to updates on, but it's been awhile since I went browsing for a new story to read just for the fun of it. It's sad that it takes something like the reading challenge to get me to read something new. I can blame part of it on a lack of time and other priorities taking precedent, but a lot of it is just that I've gotten jaded over the years. I feel like I've seen it all, read it all, and it takes a lot more for a story to hook me than it used to. I guess I'm just a lot pickier now! LOL